There are so many different types of mattress available to fit toddler beds, so often parents struggle to know which is the best to choose. Here, we have some reviews of the best foam and spring toddler mattresses, so parents can make the right choice for their needs and their budget. We also attempt to answer some common questions parents have about finding the best mattress for their growing toddler.
Spring Mattress vs Foam Mattress for Baby Review
No matter which style of mattress you are looking for, you’re sure to find the perfect product here. We have a range of foam and spring mattresses, tried and tested by parents to ensure you find something to guarantee your toddler has a great night’s sleep.
1. Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress
This Milliard mattress has a firm, supportive foam base topped with a very comfortable memory foam layer. This offers the perfect balance between comfort and support, so is sure to give your toddler a great night’s sleep. The baby crib mattress is a standard size, so it fits most cribs and toddler beds.
The kids mattress comes with a cover which is waterproof on the top and sides, yet breathable on the bottom. Air and heat can escape out the bottom of the mattress, keeping it fresh and helping it last for longer. The hypoallergenic mattress is anti-microbial making it perfect for children with asthma. The baby mattress is quiet to sleep on, meaning little ones won’t wake themselves up when they move around. It also holds it’s shape well and doesn’t start to sag after a few months.
The cheap mattress offers excellent value for money, as it can be used for several years before it will be outgrown. Children are sure to have a great sleep on the Milliard mattress, and it is very easy to care for too.
- Materials: foam, memory foam, waterproof cover
- Item weight: 12.5 pounds
- Item dimensions: 52 x 5.5 x 27.5 inches
2. Graco Crib Mattress
This toddler foam mattress comes packed in a small and lightweight box, and will expand to its full size after opening. This can take up to 72 hours, so it’s best to plan ahead to ensure the mattress arrives in plenty time before your child will be moving to their new bed. The foam is high-quality and breathable, so the risk of SIDS is minimized. The mattress is also thick enough to comfortably support a growing child – it is the only mattress you will need until your child upgrades to a bigger bed. In fact, it even comes with a 6 year warranty so you can be sure it is great quality.
The Graco mattress has a removable cover which is water-resistant, so it’s easy to keep clean if your baby or toddler has an accident. The foam is quite firm, which is safer for babies and more supportive for toddlers as they grow. Therefore, the mattress will remain comfortable for many years – making it a great investment.
- Materials: premium, breathable foam
- Item weight: 10.7 pounds
- Item dimensions: 27.6 x 52 x 5 inches
3. Dream on Me Crib Mattress
This Dream on Me mattress contains 80 interwoven spring coils, which give it a firm and supportive surface. It comes with an excellent 10 year warranty, meaning it can be used by two or three young children. This, combined with the small price tag, make this an excellent investment for families which are planning to grow.
The toddler spring mattress comes with wire around the edges, meaning it will hold its shape for years, and prevents the corners from becoming soft and worn. The mattress includes many different elements, such as air-flow systems, hypoallergenic materials and waterproof and anti-microbial bindings. This is a great mattress for 2 year old children using a toddler bed as well as babies still in a crib, as it is the right level of firmness for all needs, and fits both styles of bed.
- Materials: 80 spring coils, laminated covers
- Item weight: 10.55 pounds
- Item dimensions: 51.5 x 27.5 x 5 inches
4. Serta iComfort Hybrid
The iComfort mattress is at the higher end of the price scale but it has some amazing features which are guaranteed to help children sleep soundly through the night. It has two clearly labelled sides which offer the optimum level of support for children at different stages. One side of the Serta crib mattress is for infants, whilst the other is for toddlers – this mattress can be used for years.
The Serta toddler mattress contains gel memory foam which helps whisk away heat, keeping children cool as they sleep. The soy-enhanced foam and the gel beads offer excellent support, to ensure a safe night for babies or toddlers. There is also a waterproof-backed cover included, which is also stain resistant. This means the mattress will be looking as good as new, even if your toddler has a few accidents during the night.
- Materials: deluxe gel memory foam
- Item weight: 14.35 pounds
- Item dimensions: 52 x 27.5 x 6 inches
5. Simmons Kids 2 in 1 Mattress
This deluxe pocket spring mattress is the best cot bed mattress for infants and toddlers, who have different needs and requirements. One side is very firm for newborns and babies, whilst the other is slightly softer and more comfortable, yet still supportive, for toddlers. The mattress comes with corner protection and reinforced borders, to ensure it holds its shape and remains stable over the years.
The children’s mattress comes with a water and stain resistant cover, which contains no chemicals. The product is also Greenguard Gold certified, meaning its manufacture caused low chemical emissions – ideal for those environmentally conscious parents. The Simmons Kids is the best hybrid mattress for parents looking to get the best value for money, whilst still providing the right level of comfort and support for their child at different life stages.
- Materials: 231 pocketed coil springs, waterproof barrier
- Item weight: 21.3 pounds
- Item dimensions: 27.5 x 6 x 52 inches
What should I look for when choosing a mattress for my toddler?
The materials used in a mattress each have their own advantages and disadvantages, but which you choose is ultimately down to personal preference. However, there are other more important things to consider when choosing a mattress which is safe and comfortable for a young child. Some of the key things to consider are:
- The firmness of the mattress is important for babies and young children. They should sleep on a mattress which is quite firm, so it can support their body without becoming a suffocation hazard.
- If you are buying a mattress for a toddler bed with sides, it’s important that the mattress fits the bed perfectly, without gaps at the side which can be dangerous.
- Toddler mattresses are the same size as crib ones, so if the mattress your child used as a baby is still in good condition, there is no reason why the same one can’t be used. Some mattresses have two sides – a very firm one for infants and a more medium-firm side for toddlers. These offer great value for money, and are a good way to ensure your child is sleeping safely as they grow.
- It’s always best to buy a new mattress rather than one which has been used already. However, if you know the history of a mattress, or have used it previously for another child in the family, it’s okay to use as long as it is in good condition and hasn’t started to sag.
- A mattress which comes with a waterproof cover is a good idea for many reasons. It can of course make cleaning up after an accident a lot easier, and prevent the mattress from becoming wet or dirty. However, a waterproof cover can also help keep a mattress in better condition and prevent it from becoming softer or saggy.
What are the advantages of a foam mattress?
Foam mattresses are lightweight, and tend to offer the best value for money. They also offer a good level of support, and are comfortable. Most foam mattresses for toddlers also come with a wipe clean plastic covering, meaning it’s easier to keep it clean. Whilst they are ideal for a few years, after this time they can start to lose their shape, so they’re not ideal for big families who plan on using the mattress for future children.
What are the advantages of a spring mattress?
The traditional coil spring mattress is great for many reasons. The spring core offers a great level of support, and the spaces between the springs allow air to flow through the mattress. This keeps the child feeling cooler, and helps keep the mattress fresh. Spring mattresses tend to be longer lasting than foam mattresses, so are ideal for families where they will be used for more than one child. However, spring mattresses tend to be more expensive than their foam counterparts, so unless the mattress will be used for more than one child, or will be used by one child for many years, they are not always the best value for money.
Final thoughts and our conclusions
There are many great toddler mattresses out there, and it’s really down to personal preference which material you should choose. If you are on a tighter budget and plan to use the mattress for only one child, it might be best to choose a foam mattress. The best affordable mattress is probably the Milliard – it has some great features and is quiet and comfortable for infants as well as toddlers.
For families where there will be more than one child using a mattress, it’s a good idea to consider a longer-lasting spring mattress or high-end foam mattress, which can be used for many years without loosing it’s support. We think the Serta iComfort is the best mattress for 3 year old children – it is sure to win over even the fussiest of sleepers with its superior comfort filling.
Once you have found the right mattress for your toddler, you might also like to think about getting them their first pillow to really help them get a great night’s sleep.